Cheesy Chicken Stuffed Peppers

The first time I made stuffed peppers, I was standing in my kitchen on a random Tuesday evening, staring at four bright bell peppers I'd picked up on impulse. I had some leftover rotisserie chicken from the weekend, a handful of rice, and cheese—always cheese. Within an hour, something golden and bubbling emerged from the oven that felt like I'd actually planned dinner instead of improvised it. My kitchen smelled incredible, and that's when I knew this would become one of those recipes I'd return to again and again.

I served these to my sister and her family on a chilly autumn evening, and watching my nephew go back for seconds made me understand why people get excited about stuffed peppers. There's something satisfying about a meal that looks put-together but doesn't require you to stress in the kitchen. That night, dinner felt like an achievement.

Ingredients

• Bell peppers (4 large, any color): Choose ones that stand upright without wobbling—this keeps them from tipping over in the dish while baking. Mix colors if you want visual drama.
• Cooked chicken (2 cups, shredded): Rotisserie chicken is your shortcut to flavor and tenderness without extra work. Leftover roasted or poached chicken works equally well.
• Cooked rice (1 cup): White rice is classic, but brown adds nuttiness. Day-old rice actually works better than freshly cooked because it's less sticky.
• Cheddar cheese, shredded (1 1/2 cups, divided): Don't skip shredding it yourself if possible—pre-shredded contains anti-caking agents that prevent that gorgeous melted layer.
• Cream cheese (1/4 cup, softened): This acts as a binder and adds richness without heaviness. Let it sit on the counter while you prep everything else.
• Onion and garlic: Sautéing them first mellows their sharpness and infuses the entire filling with depth.
• Diced tomatoes (1 can, 14 oz, drained): Draining them is crucial—extra liquid will make the filling watery and the peppers soggy.
• Italian herbs, smoked paprika, salt, and black pepper: These seasonings create layers of warmth without any single flavor dominating.
• Olive oil (2 tablespoons): Use enough to coat the skillet properly so your aromatics develop flavor instead of sticking.

Instructions

Prep your peppers:

Slice the tops off and scoop out every last seed and white membrane—these can taste bitter if left behind. Stand each pepper in the baking dish to see how they'll sit; a slight tilt is fine, but they shouldn't list like a sinking ship.

Wake up your aromatics:

Heat the olive oil and let the onion soften until it turns translucent and sweet, then add garlic for just 30 seconds—any longer and it burns and turns acrid. You'll smell the moment it's right.

Build your filling:

In a large bowl, combine the chicken, rice, sautéed vegetables, drained tomatoes, one cup of cheese, softened cream cheese, and all your seasonings. Stir until everything is evenly distributed and the cream cheese has mostly dissolved into the mixture.

Fill and top:

Spoon the filling into each pepper, packing it gently but not so tight that it compacts. Scatter the remaining cheese across the tops—this will create a golden, crispy crust as it bakes.

Add steam:

Pour 2-3 tablespoons of water into the bottom of the baking dish around the peppers. This creates steam that cooks them gently and prevents the bottom from burning.

Bake in two stages:

Cover with foil for the first 25 minutes so the peppers steam and soften, then uncover and bake another 10 minutes until the cheese is bubbly and golden and the pepper skin shows just the faintest char marks. This two-step approach keeps the peppers tender while browning the top perfectly.

Cool before serving:

Let them sit for a few minutes after coming out of the oven—this helps them hold their shape and gives the filling time to set slightly so it doesn't spill out when you lift them onto a plate.

Save to Pinterest

There's a quiet joy in serving something homemade that looks like you spent hours on it when you really didn't. These peppers taught me that impressive dinners don't require complicated techniques, just thoughtfulness about how ingredients work together.

Variations Worth Trying

The beauty of this recipe is how forgiving it is with substitutions. Swap the rice for cauliflower rice if you're looking for lower carbs, or use cooked quinoa if you want a protein boost. Spinach or corn stirred into the filling adds texture and nutrition without changing the core flavors. For heat, a pinch of chili flakes or minced jalapeños tucked into the filling transforms it from comforting to exciting.

What to Serve Alongside

A simple green salad with a sharp vinaigrette cuts through the richness of the cheese and peppers beautifully. Garlic bread is always welcome if anyone wants carbs. I've also had success serving these with a chilled cucumber salad or roasted vegetables on the side—anything fresh feels like the right complement.

Make-Ahead and Storage Tips

You can assemble these peppers up to 12 hours ahead and refrigerate them covered before baking—add a few extra minutes to the cooking time since they'll start cold. Leftovers reheat beautifully in a 350°F oven for about 15 minutes. They also freeze well before baking if you want to stockpile easy dinners for busier weeks.

• Refrigerate cooked peppers in an airtight container for up to 4 days.
• Freeze unbaked peppers for up to 3 months wrapped individually in plastic wrap then foil.
• Thaw frozen peppers in the fridge overnight before baking, then cook as written.

Save to Pinterest

These stuffed peppers have become my go-to when I want to feel organized without actually being organized. They're the kind of meal that satisfies everyone at the table.